Compliance does not = LEADERSHIP

Image:Keith Srakocic/Associated Press


This post is not about compliance as a legal or regulatory requirement. It is about compliance as an attitude that means ‘do as you’re told, no questions’, with followers and team members reduced to the status of drones. Leaders aiming for this sort of compliance are kidding themselves; it’s a sure sign of having your priorities wrong.

I have a good friend, now the CEO of a global brand, who in a previous career was serving as the second in command (2ic) of an Infantry company, (A fighting unit of around 100 men). The Boss was an autocratic and impatient individual who demanded unquestioning obedience. In fact he quickly established a separate reality for himself, as nobody would tell him the truth. On one occasion during a period of intensive pre-deployment training, he commented to his second in command, my friend, how well everything was going and how high the Company’s morale was.   His second in command of course agreed, that was the culture, but even as he nodded his assent he had to stifle a grim laugh. The 2ic had just conducted his own discussion with members of the Company and had learnt how a number of them had that afternoon, appropriated the Commander’s combat jacket and burnt it to ashes. A petty act of pointless rebellion but also a symbolic act of subversion that gave the lie to how the company really felt about their ‘leader’.

The underpinning assumption of this sort of leadership is that you have all the answers, to all the problems. Quite a conceit! This may be born of arrogance in some, in others it’s weakness masquerading as strength, a chronic lack of self-confidence and a fragile ego, guarding an underlying sense of inadequacy with bluff and aggression.   More damaging still is that this persona is not simply exhibited in individuals but becomes an established norm within the culture of many organizations. It’s certainly a key ingredient of toxic leadership and a toxic culture.


Here’s a quick summary of some of the damage this kind of leadership does:


  • Compliance shuts down debate and limits creative problem solving and innovation. In this culture you get minimal engagement, reluctant coerced followers looking to survive or get out. Organizations try to flank the problem by creating skunk works & clustering their mavericks (independent speakers of truth, usually labelled as disloyal, poor team-players). What an irony that innovation basically equals how well we are able to subvert our own rules and inertia! See this recent Wired example, at face value great work being done but at the same time symptomatic of other problems, one of which is a culture of compliance.


  • Compliance creates a culture that avoids truth. We don’t say what we mean, feedback is non-existent or contaminated with the platitudes of what the boss wants to hear. In this atmosphere nothing and nobody improves beyond good enough, which is another way of saying performance is crap compared to what it could be.


  • Compliance breeds anxiety and fear. Effort and focus are diverted to exhibiting ‘correct’ behaviour or answers. Acquiescence becomes a survival strategy in an environment awash with cortisol.


  • Compliance misunderstands loyalty. Loyalty should mean freedom and responsibility to challenge, to be honest, to give feedback. Loyalty should be first to the mission and the organization and only then to the leader and they’d better be clear that loyalty is earned not owed.


Team members unfortunately often end up being complicit in this toxic soup. We’re strongly socialised from infancy to be compliant toward authority. Our school years push it into our marrow and its compounded in a typical work hierarchy.

To be an effective team member you need to believe you are valued; not just by individual leaders but also by the organization those leaders represent. To be truly effective authority must reside in the hearts of followers. Leaders are only ever truly legitimized and given authority by the actions of those who choose to follow them. An imposed authority is always merely tolerated and eventually you will reap what you have sown.

Related Posts

Too busy Judging when we should be developing

We have been working with several groups of leaders recently who are in the midst of the annual cycle of performance reviews. This often involves talent identification, evaluations and various pigeonholing tools like 9-box grids, success circles and values matrices.   My problem is not simply with the tools or…

Read more
Accidental Leadership – Unbundling the App

For most leaders the process of becoming a leader is accidental. You start a career and build technical competence. If you are good at what you do there often comes a point when you get given responsibility for other people, which in theory at least, means you are now a…

Read more
Freedom Inside Constraints

The Legendary Basketball coach John Wooden[1], would begin each new season by sitting down his new players and demonstrating to them how they were to tie the laces on their shoes.  Surely unnecessary? – These athletes had been playing the game for years. Wooden’s point, was that for many things…

Read more
Women obeserving passers by
What Do You Notice?

  ‘Clarity begins with realizing what we do not notice—and don’t notice that we don’t notice’.   Sir Alex Ferguson the legendary former coach of football club Manchester United was quite clear in his leadership philosophy and approach to coaching that the ability to notice what was going on, to…

Read more