The Problem with Authority

Authority [mass noun] the power or right to give orders, make decisions, and enforce obedience: he had absolute authority over his subordinates.

An ‘authority gradient’ is a way of imagining how far and how steep the gap is between leaders and team members. The higher and steeper that gap the more formal the structures and relationships will be in the organization.

When I joined the army it was very clear that the authority gradient was large and precipitous. Even amongst Lieutenants – the most junior commissioned officers there were sharp gradations between those who were senior and those who were not. Rank amongst Lieutenants is like virtue amongst whores but the status seniority bequeathed to itself was an unfortunate part of the organisational culture: Unfortunate because authority usually gets in the way of developing performance. It stops discussion – too busy being important to engage in debate or challenge. It resists feedback, tending both to formalize this into systems for performance management and to ensure it only moves downwards. It gets in the way of learning. It lacks the humility to be curios, open minded and willing to fail or make mistakes. Authority leadership is all about personal ego protecting an image and using privilege to protect status. In my military experience authoritarian leadership invariably came from weakness. The weaker and more inadequate the leader the greater their reliance on authority.

I saw this picture change when I left the conventional military and arrived in a Special Forces unit. The authority gradient here was both short and shallow. The leadership culture was open to challenge, sought out and encouraged feedback and was good at learning quickly.

What’s the authority gradient in your team or organisation? If you use this as a health marker what does it tell you?


Metris Leadership helps businesses build high performance teams, optimized for the challenges of the 21st Century because great teams provide standout competitive advantage.

To find out how we could help you contact us at

Related Posts

Freedom Inside Constraints

The Legendary Basketball coach John Wooden[1], would begin each new season by sitting down his new players and demonstrating to them how they were to tie the laces on their shoes.  Surely unnecessary? – These athletes had been playing the game for years. Wooden’s point, was that for many things…

Read more
Women obeserving passers by
What Do You Notice?

  ‘Clarity begins with realizing what we do not notice—and don’t notice that we don’t notice’.   Sir Alex Ferguson the legendary former coach of football club Manchester United was quite clear in his leadership philosophy and approach to coaching that the ability to notice what was going on, to…

Read more
What Do We Remember?

‘…a war begun for no purpose, carried on with a strange mixture of rashness and timidity, brought to a close after suffering and disaster, without much glory attached either to the government which directed, or the great body of troops which waged it. Not one benefit, political or military, was…

Read more
Are You Listening Or Just Letting Me Speak?

‘The single biggest problem with communication is the illusion that it has taken place’ George Bernard Shaw We know that good communication depends in good measure on listening but we mostly spend too little time thinking about what that really means. Listening is usually passive, in the sense that it…

Read more